Description & PlansCitadel Home PageCompliance CertificationQuality Enhancement PlanReferenced DocumentsWork in ProgressReaffirmation Home Page

Closing the Loop: Fourteen Examples
in Summary Form of Improvements
Brought about by Assessment

In Academics

• Chemistry Laboratories
• Engineering Curriculum and Laboratories
• Modern Language Laboratory
• Electronic Databases in Daniel Library
• Reading Tutorial Program

In Student Affairs

• Freshman Student Activity Space
• Class Absence System
• Fitness Center and Equipment
• Barracks (Residence Hall) Supervision
• Honor Training for Students

In Athletics

• Women's Intercollegiate Athletics Programs

In College Administration

• Freshman Retention Programs
• Reorganization to Schools
• Faculty Salary Supplements

 

Academics

Chemistry Laboratories

For a number of years prior to 2000-01, the annual assessment reports from the Department of Chemistry indicated a critical need to upgrade its general chemistry labs and to develop several special-purpose labs.

As a result of these assessments, The Citadel developed a proposal and presented it to a distinguished Citadel graduate who had earned a Ph.D. in chemistry and taught chemistry at the Air Force Academy. In December 2000, Dr. Harvey Schiller pledged $500,000 to refurbish general purpose chemistry labs and to develop a biochemistry lab in support of a new joint minor offered by the Departments of Biology and Chemistry.

This project, resulting directly from departmental assessment of facilities and programs, has now been completed.

Engineering Curriculum and Laboratories

The annual assessment reports from the Departments of Civil and Environmental Engineering and Electrical and Computer Engineering indicated the need to improve and update lab equipment. This need, as well as the need to revise the curriculum in several areas, was identified and validated in the 1997 ABET review of these two programs.

As a result of this assessment, the faculty have implemented the necessary curriculum revisions, and the institution has allocated additional funding to improve the laboratories in these two departments. The project will be implemented over a three-year period.

These needs surfaced as a result of annual departmental assessment and the reaffirmation review of The Citadel's programs by ABET.

Modern Language Laboratory

In addition to the annual assessment reports from the Department of Modern Languages, The Citadel, in conjunction with the South Carolina Commission on Higher Education, conducts program reviews. Both the departmental assessment and the 2000 program review identified the language laboratory as a major problem area within the modern languages program.

As a result of these two assessments, the institution reviewed several alternatives for transitioning from a "boom-box and tape" operation to a modern, computer-based language laboratory.

Following this review, the institution funded the renovation of the facility and the procurement of the necessary software and hardware to develop a state-of-the-art, computer-based laboratory. In addition, the institution funds a faculty member to be in charge of the laboratory and to assess the ongoing performance of the lab in meeting the curriculum requirements of the department. This faculty member also provides training on the use of the lab.

This significant educational improvement came about as a result of departmental assessment and periodic program review.

Electronic Databases in Daniel Library

Daniel Library conducts annual surveys to determine satisfaction with library services. These surveys, coupled with national trends regarding the storage and retrieval of academic materials, led The Citadel to increase the investment in electronic databases.

In addition, the institution has secured grant funds and private donations for this purpose. The institution has dramatically increased access to multiple electronic databases during the last three years as a result of this assessment.

Reading Tutorial Program

The Core Curriculum portions of the Annual Assessment Reports from the Departments of English and History identified a significant number of entering freshmen with reading problems. As a result, The Citadel began administering the Nelson-Denny reading test to all incoming freshmen in the fall of 2000. The results were analyzed by faculty members with a specialty in reading in the Department of Education.

As a result of this assessment data, the institution developed a reading tutorial program that is provided through OASIS (Office of Access Services, Instruction, and Support) at no cost to the student.

The Nelson-Denny is now given to each freshman as a routine part of freshman orientation, and incoming freshmen are referred to the Reading Tutorial program based upon the results. The institution allocated the resources for this program based on the important need which surfaced as a result of our assessment program.

 

Student Affairs

Freshman Student Activity Space

The Citadel periodically conducts formal studies of the entire freshman year (Fourth Class System) in addition to annual assessment done by the Provost and Commandant of Cadets on freshman attrition and academic performance. Parts of these studies include contracting with a third party to do a follow-up study on all freshmen who leave The Citadel during their first semester (fall). In addition, the Board of Visitors, through the committee structure, reviews areas of special interest.

The annual studies indicated the need for a freshman snack area and lounge. The institution studied this need more carefully and validated the importance of these new facilities.

The Commandant's Office and the food service contractor redesigned the existing snack bar space to include a private area for freshmen. In addition, a new lounge area was developed by the institution in Mark Clark Hall. These new spaces became operational in the Fall of 2002 as a result of the assessment of the experiences of our freshmen. The Offices of the Commandant of Cadets and the Vice President for Finance and Business Affairs are continuing to assess the impacts of these new facilities on freshman attrition and performance.

Class Absence System

At The Citadel, class attendance is required, and cadets are disciplined for unexcused class absences. The system developed for reporting and processing class absences was in the main manual and quite cumbersome. Annual assessment tools, including cadet surveys and focus group meetings with cadet leaders and selected faculty, indicated that this reporting system was actually exacerbating the class absence system because additional disciplinary consequences were resulting from the time delays caused by delays in the processing system.

Based on these assessments and the review of discipline by the Commandant's Office, The Citadel reviewed best practices regarding cadet accountability systems. Members of the Commandant's Office and Information Technology Services visited West Point to review that accountability system. Based on the analysis of best practices and the institution's identification of the problem through institutional assessment, The Citadel has redesigned its class absence system. The new system is an online system which is driven by faculty input. The data becomes available daily to the student; to upperclassmen in charge; and to tactical officers, adults who are assigned to each cadet barracks.

The Citadel's Information Technology Services has designed, developed, and tested the new system, and it will become fully operational in Fall 2003. This enhancement is a direct result of the assessment of student (cadet) life, analysis of the current discipline system, and faculty concerns.

Fitness Center and Equipment

The Citadel periodically conducts studies of the freshman year (Fourth Class System). In addition, annual studies are done by the Provost and Commandant of Cadets on freshman attrition and academic performance. The institution also does an annual exit survey of all seniors. In addition, the Athletics Department surveys the interest of female freshmen as input in the determination of the mix of intercollegiate sports programs. Finally, the Athletics Department does an exit interview with each athlete when they graduate or leave the institution.

These assessments coupled with the known trends regarding increased interest in fitness among college students led The Citadel to make significant improvements in the fitness rooms and equipment for student athletes and the entire student body.

Also, The Citadel's physical plant assessment of deferred maintenance supported this need for improvements in the facility (Deas Hall). As a result of this assessment, The Citadel invested state funds and obtained private donations to make major improvements in Deas Hall including the weight room and fitness areas. The total investment is approximately 2.5 million dollars. The project was done in phases and the last phase will be completed at the end of August 2003.

Barracks (Residence Hall) Supervision

The Office of the Commandant of Cadets prepares an annual report that includes an assessment of discipline issues in the barracks. In addition, in 2002 the institution conducted a thorough review of barracks security and the fourth class system.

Based upon these studies, the Commandant proposed a significant enhancement of the adult supervision in the barracks during the evening. The institution approved and funded this new program which includes the provision of an adult officer-in-charge (OC) for each of the four barracks from 8:00 p.m. until 7:30 a.m. In addition, there is a supervising OC on duty during this period to assist the four OC's as necessary.

This program became fully operational for the 2002-03 year, and the Commandant's Office continues to monitor its success. First-year results on the assessment of the new program are encouraging as the number of serious discipline issues decreased significantly.

Honor Training for Students

The Cadet Honor Code plays a critical role in the accomplishment of The Citadel's primary mission of educating its graduates to become principled leaders. Monitoring the number and nature of honor offenses is part of the annual assessment of cadet life. Based on these assessments, that include interviews of freshmen who have decided to leave the College, The Citadel determined that there was a need for enhanced training regarding the Cadet Honor Code and what it truly means to live by that code.

In 2002 the institution conducted a Systems Review of 1) ethics and honor, 2) multicultural relationships, 3) student-athlete issues, 4) barracks safety and security, and 5) the fourth class experience.

This review validated the need for additional training on the Cadet Honor Code, and a committee, chaired by the faculty advisor to the Cadet Honor Committee, developed a computer-based approach to individual instruction on the Cadet Honor Code. The system was tested with a group of cadets and will become part of cadet training in academic year 2003-04.

In addition to the development of this instructional system, the institution invested in the necessary upgrade to software to enable the system to be available to all cadets. Finally, the institution developed a proposal to fund a leadership initiative at The Citadel including a Director of the Krause Initiative in Leadership reporting directly to the President. This proposal was funded, and the director has been selected. This individual will work with the faculty advisor to the Cadet Honor Committee to continue to assess the effectiveness of this online instructional program.

Women's Intercollegiate Athletic Programs

In 1996 The Citadel made the decision to admit women into its primary student body, the South Carolina Corps of Cadets. The institution also made a commitment to remain in the Southern Conference and in Division I of the NCAA . Therefore, the institution initiated a comprehensive assessment program to determine the athletic interests of new female students and prospects. This assessment was a major factor in the determination of the seven sports for women currently offered by The Citadel. The timetable for implementation was as follows:

1997-98: Cross Country, Indoor Track, Outdoor Track

1998-99: Volleyball

2000-01: Soccer, Golf

2001-02: Rifle

As a result of these assessments and plans, The Citadel has implemented seven intercollegiate athletic sports for women with a total annual investment of approximately $750,000.

A part of the NCAA certification of the athletic program at The Citadel included the development of gender and minority equity plans for intercollegiate athletics at The Citadel. The assessment of the implementation of these plans resulted in significant improvements in institutional systems and procedures including hiring practices; representation of students, faculty, and staff on committees; surveys of students; facilities and support services for student athletes; and the number of women professionals involved in the athletic programs at The Citadel.

The Citadel continues to assess this issue through annual surveys and program reviews.

 

College Administration

Freshman Retention Program

The Citadel periodically conducts formal studies of the entire freshman year (Fourth Class System) in addition to the annual assessment done by the Provost and Commandant on freshman attrition and academic performance. A part of these studies includes contracting with a third party to do a follow-up study on all freshmen who leave The Citadel during their first semester (fall).

The results of these annual assessment reports, formal studies, external contracted studies, and national research in higher education indicated the need to provide additional support for students transitioning from high school to college and from a civilian environment to a more structured military-oriented environment.

Based on this assessment, the institution developed two additional programs for freshmen. Citadel 101 is a one-credit-hour course that is required for all first-time freshmen for each fall semester. The course is a fairly typical freshman orientation course taught by regular faculty and a few staff/administrators.

In addition to Citadel 101, the institution developed an early intervention program, "Jump Start," which is mandatory for freshmen who do not perform well during the fall semester of their freshman year. The program consists of tutoring sessions on time management, study skills, test taking, and other appropriate topics. In addition, these students are required to limit their course loads for the spring semester of their freshman year. The data from the first year of implementation showed a significant improvement in the freshman grade point ratio and a significant decrease in attrition. The institution continues to monitor these programs annually. These programs were developed and funded as a direct result of efforts to assess the experience of the first-year students.

Reorganization to Schools

For a number of years, the institution studied the organizational structure of the academic programs at The Citadel. The previous Vice President for Academic Affairs recommended the change of the Department of Education to the School of Education in the Spring of 1999. The new Vice President for Academic Affairs (now Provost) decided to study the entire structure. A process which included significant faculty input as well as input from the Faculty Council and Academic Board (academic administrators) was undertaken and continued for approximately 18 months.

The results of this assessment led the institution to reorganize into five schools as follows:
School of Business Administration
School of Education
School of Engineering
School of Humanities and Social Sciences
School of Science and Mathematics

All five schools are operational. Four of the five now have deans, and the fifth school (Science and Mathematics) has an acting dean for the 2003-04 academic year. The Provost continues to monitor the impact of this reorganization.

Faculty Salary Supplements

As a part of ongoing assessment, the Office of the Provost and the Office of Institutional Planning and Assessment conduct annual salary studies using data from 29 peer institutions. Between 1997 and 1999, this data indicated the need for faculty salary increases at The Citadel in order for the institution to be competitive in recruiting and retaining faculty.

As a result of this assessment data, The Citadel allocated $440,000 in additional faculty salary supplement funds from The Citadel Foundation to address merit, market, and equity issues.

The institution continues to conduct this annual salary study approach as a part of its ongoing assessment program.